Shepherd’s Pie with Toasted Leeks and Irish Cheddar

Posted on | March 15, 2009 | 5 Comments

The cheddar and leeks make this shepherd's pie

Shepherd’s Pie With Leeks and Irish Cheddar

Technorati Profile

The original recipe for this is from Delia Smith, a U.K. food writer. Her recipes are phenomenal and it’s a crime that we don’t see more of her on this side of the pond. For more on Delia, visit her Web site at: www.deliaonline.com

I’ve modified it a bit from the last time I posted it in November to include a blend of meats, peas and a bit more spice. This dish, as outlined below, will easily serve 8 people – perfect for a St. Paddy’s day dinner.

For this recipe, I used 1 pound of lamb and 1 pound of ground turkey as a healthier alternative to beef.  One can of course make shepherd’s pie with any ground meat, but it’s the lamb that makes it; the subtle gaminess that plays through all the spices and toppings – the foundation upon which shepherd’s pie is really built.

1 lb lamb and lb ground turkey

2 tbs olive oil
2 medium yellow onions, chopped
3-4 carrots, chopped finely
2-3 medium sized turnips, chopped finely
1 cup peas (add toward the end).
1 tbs Thyme, adding more to taste as the recipe comes together
1 tbs parsley, fresh (dried will work as well, but in that case use double)

1 heaping tbsp cinnamon (The original recipe calls for a half teaspoon, but I really like the cinnamon flavor n in this dish and like to add a bit more. So, I might start with the teaspoon and  add then supplement to taste)

1 teaspoon bay leaf

1 tbs plain white flour
10 oz beef stock
1 ½ tbs of tomato puree (I like to add a small bit of water and the puree to a bowl and mix it up into a lighter paste. It makes it easier to mix to the remainder of ingredients)
salt and pepper to taste (I do this early to give these time to blend in. Use kosher salt if possible)
Apple cider vinegar (this isn’t in the recipe, but I like to add the smallest bit of apple cider vinegar if the above comes out a bit salty. Tough to tell with the meat and stock mixture. If you want to tone down the salt, the vinegar helps. But, this is up to you)

Topping:

2oz Dubliner Irish Cheddar, grated, but not too fine (I like to leave it out for a half hour, or so, before I use it. It opens up a bit)
2 Leeks cut into bits (three if you can only find the small ones. HOWEVER, green onions also work very well. In this case, chop enough to get good coverage on the top of the pie)
2lb mashing potatoes of your choice
2 oz butter (Don’t use too much and don’t use cream or milk as the mash needs to sit on top of the pie.)
Salt and pepper (I like the mash to be very peppery, but this up to you)

Use an oval or large rectangular baking dish.

Heat olive oil in a larger frying pan over medium heat. Fry onions until just colored. Don’t burn the edges. 5-7 minutes.

Add the carrots and the turnip and cook for about 5 more minutes, stirring every so often. Pull the veg when they look thoroughly cooked.

Brown meat in the pan. I like to do this in batches so you get good coverage and the pan doesn’t get too cold. Season with salt and pepper. Add the vegetables, cinnamon, thyme, parsley (NOTE: you may need to remove some fat depending on the meat you choose. If it looks overly fatty, remove some, not all, with a spoon. This wasn’t an issue with the turkey).

Add the flour to soak up the juices. Gradually add the stock while stirring. Add the tomato puree. Put a lid, turn the heat down to simmer/low and heat for about 25 minutes.

While this is simmering, make the topping.

Chop the potatoes into quarters, add salt to boiling water and Cook potatoes for 20 minutes until tender.

(If you choose, now is when to give the leeks a quick 2-3 minutes on medium heat just to break them down a bit. Your choice. The green onions won’t need it.)

Pre-heat the oven to 400.

When the potatoes are done, return to pot, covering with tea towel for 5-7 minute to absorb the steam.

Add the butter and pepper and mash to a smooth, but not cream, consistency. Taste and add salt and pepper as needed (you can also add other herbs here, if you like)

Uncover the meat mixture and let some of the liquid cook off for 2-3 minutes (this would be the time to add the peas, if you choose). When it looks like a thick chili consistency, spoon into a buttered dish (a quick spray of pam will do). Level the meat mixture out so that it’s even. Spoon the mash mixture over the top, spreading so that it’s even and covers the meat to the dish rim. Sprinkle the leeks or onions on top of the potatoes and scatter the grated cheese over the leeks.

Bake until the cheese is gold brown with a slight crust and the dish is bubbling.

NOTE: This dish will stay hot for a long time. Give it some time to set outside the oven in the kitchen as it will be too hot to eat immediately out of the oven.

Serve with peas, a bitter lettuce salad with a simple vinaigrette and crusty bread fresh from the oven.

Pair with Leffe Belgian Beer or Irish Stout. This also handles a nice spicy malbec, chianti, or not-too-oaky Cab.

Comments

5 Responses to “Shepherd’s Pie with Toasted Leeks and Irish Cheddar”

  1. M.W.
    December 9th, 2008 @ 8:04 pm

    I love this recipe! One of my all-time favorites.

  2. Jenni
    March 17th, 2009 @ 12:00 am

    Good lord, Will! Are you trying to kill me?! That looks absolutely wonderful!

  3. M.W.
    March 17th, 2009 @ 1:25 pm

    I commented on this a while ago but I can’t resist commenting again. This is one of my absolute favorite recipes from this site! Love it!

  4. JLB
    May 14th, 2009 @ 12:50 pm

    When I grew up our Shepherd’s pie was ALWAYS made with leftover leg of lamb. It drives me crazy that everytime I see it, it’s made with ground beef. It looks like nothing more than Beef a Roni in a pan. I see you use lamb, though you list an alternative. Thank you for that. I bet the leeks make this wonderful. I may have to try it!

    JLB’s last blog post..My camera is still broken

  5. Columbus Foodie » Blog Archive » March 2009 Roundup
    July 19th, 2009 @ 10:34 pm

    [...] and Egg Spring Pizza from Pro Bono Baker, Grilled Ham Steaks from Recipe Collector and Tester, Shepherd’s Pie with Toasted Leeks and Irish Cheddar from Recipe Play, Thai Red Curry with Chicken Thighs, Sweet Potatoes and Fresh Bamboo Shoots from [...]

Leave a Reply